Women's Basketball Team Stands Up for Trans Teammate, Refuses to Play

In a powerful show of support, the Vancouver Island University (VIU) Mariners women's basketball team made headlines by refusing to play against Columbia Bible College (CBC) due to the treatment of their transgender teammate, Harriette Mackenzie. The incident unfolded after previous games between the two teams where Mackenzie had excelled, scoring 19 points and securing 16 rebounds, leading to a victory for the Mariners.

However, Mackenzie’s outstanding performance was overshadowed by controversy. Taylor Claggett, the head coach of CBC, reportedly complained about Mackenzie having an "unfair" advantage because she is a trans woman, despite her evident skill and dedication to the sport. This complaint was further fueled by Coach Claggett's brother, Kyle, who resorted to social media to voice his gender-critical views, misgendering Mackenzie and questioning her place in women’s sports.

The situation escalated during the subsequent game, where CBC players allegedly engaged in rough play and verbal taunting towards Mackenzie. One particularly aggressive incident saw Mackenzie being pulled to the ground, resulting in a flagrant foul. Mackenzie later expressed that these actions were rooted in the transphobic attitudes exhibited by the opposing team’s coaching staff.

In response to the hostility and lack of action from the Pacific Western Athletic Association (PACWEST), the VIU Mariners took a stand. The team decided collectively not to participate in a scheduled game against CBC, highlighting their concerns about safety and sportsmanship. Their decision echoes past actions by the San Diego Loyal, a team that refused to continue a match in response to homophobic behavior, showcasing a growing trend of athletes standing up against discrimination in sports.

In a letter addressed to VIU and PACWEST officials, the team articulated their stance clearly, stating, “We need you to know that we are not OK with what happened. We don’t feel safe playing at CBC or with that team so long as Coach Claggett is still free to behave the way she did. Your inaction isn’t just disappointing. It has made us and the game less safe.”

This act of solidarity has done more than just highlight the issue of transphobia in sports; it has united the team and their supporters. The Mariners have received an outpouring of support from fans, who have been seen waving transgender pride flags alongside the team's colors, symbolizing unity and acceptance.

Harriette Mackenzie, who faced similar challenges at a previous college in Alberta, has found a supportive community at VIU. Her achievements, including being named a Canadian Collegiate Athletic Association Player of the Year and contributing to a CCAA championship win, speak to her talent and resilience.

The incident has also sparked broader conversations about the inclusion of transgender athletes in sports. As Canada approaches a federal election, with conservative voices echoing sentiments similar to those seen in the U.S., the personal becomes political for athletes like Mackenzie. Yet, the strength shown by the VIU Mariners and their fans suggests they are prepared for these challenges.

The team's letter concluded with a powerful message: “All of us should be free to be ourselves and play the game we love in a supportive and safe environment, including queer and trans athletes.” By refusing to back down, the Mariners have set a precedent, encouraging others to speak out and take action against discrimination.

As they prepare to face Camosun College in upcoming games, the controversy with CBC remains unresolved. The PACWEST continues to investigate the incident, and the games are listed as "postponed." Meanwhile, the VIU Mariners remain steadfast in their commitment to ensuring safety and inclusivity in sports.

This story of courage and defiance serves as an inspiration, illustrating the power of unity and the importance of standing up for what is right, both on and off the court.

Stay informed on this developing story and others impacting LGBTQ athletes by subscribing to our newsletter.