EEOC Withdraws Workplace Harassment Guidance Amidst Trans Rights Controversy

The U.S. Equal Employment Opportunity Commission (EEOC) recently made a significant decision that has sparked controversy and concern within the LGBTQ+ community. The commission voted to rescind its most recent workplace harassment guidance, which had included important protections and examples related to gender identity and sexual orientation.

This decision was made following a 2-to-1 vote on Thursday, with EEOC Chair Andrea Lucas and Commissioner Brittany Panuccio, both appointees of former President Donald Trump, voting in favor of rescinding the guidance. Commissioner Kalpana Kotagal, the sole Democrat on the commission, voted against the move.

Background and Implications

The guidance in question was approved in 2024 under the Biden administration. It was based on the 2020 Supreme Court decision in Bostock v. Clayton County, which affirmed that discrimination based on gender identity and sexual orientation is a form of sex-based discrimination under Title VII of the Civil Rights Act of 1964. The guidance included crucial examples of unlawful workplace discrimination, such as the intentional misuse of pronouns that do not align with an employee’s gender identity, as well as the denial of access to restrooms that match an employee’s gender identity.

Lucas, who was an EEOC commissioner at the time the guidance was originally approved, opposed it, arguing in her dissent that "Biological sex is real, and it matters. Sex is binary (male and female) and is immutable." She contended that acknowledging these "truths" should not be considered harassment, even if it involves the use of pronouns that reflect these views.

Political and Legal Context

Following President Trump’s decision to appoint Lucas as the EEOC’s acting chair, she has expressed opposition to diversity, equity, and inclusion (DEI) initiatives and federal civil rights protections for transgender individuals. Her stated priorities include "rooting out unlawful DEI-motivated race and sex discrimination." In January 2025, Trump issued an executive order declaring that the U.S. government would only recognize an individual’s sex as either male or female, as determined by "immutable biological classification."

Lucas declared that while the EEOC would continue accepting all discrimination charges, complaints that "implicate" the anti-trans executive order would be escalated for review. Despite these actions, the EEOC resumed processing complaints that align with the legal precedent set by the Bostock decision in July 2025.

Legal Challenges and Criticism

In May 2025, a federal judge ruled that the EEOC exceeded its authority with the updated 2024 guidance and vacated the sections related to anti-LGBTQ+ workplace harassment. Although this judicial decision, along with the rescission of the guidance, does not change federal laws protecting LGBTQ+ workers from discrimination, it removes a key resource for employers trying to understand what constitutes unlawful harassment.

Commissioner Kotagal criticized the decision to rescind the guidance entirely, as it was done without a notice and comment period typically required for such changes. "There’s no reason to rescind the harassment guidance in its entirety," she stated. "Instead of adopting a thoughtful and surgical approach to excise the sections the majority disagrees with or suggest an alternative, the commission is throwing out the baby with the bathwater. Worse, it is doing so without public input."

Thursday’s vote has left many employers uncertain about navigating issues of harassment, with former EEOC Chair Charlotte Burrows and employment law expert Craig Leen noting the lack of public transparency about the commission’s approach to complex harassment issues.

The LGBTQ+ community and its allies are encouraged to remain vigilant and continue advocating for inclusive and fair workplace policies that protect against discrimination based on gender identity and sexual orientation. As the landscape of federal guidance and legal interpretation continues to evolve, staying informed and involved is crucial for ensuring equality and protection for all workers.

Stay updated with the latest news and insights by subscribing to our newsletter, dedicated to bringing you the most important developments affecting the LGBTQ+ community.