Charges Dismissed for Soldiers After Flag Theft, Opt for Restorative Justice

In an unexpected turn of events, charges have been dismissed against two young soldiers who were apprehended last year for recurrently stealing Pride flags from a lesbian couple's residence in Arlington, Virginia. The incident, which attracted significant public attention, unfolded as a story of potential redemption through a novel justice approach.

It all began in February of last year when police arrested Matthew Henshaw, then 20, and Joseph DiGregorio, 23, both stationed at Joint Base Fort Meyer-Henderson Hall. These soldiers were part of the prestigious Army’s 3rd U.S. Infantry Regiment, colloquially known as The Old Guard. Henshaw faced three counts each of bias-motivated unlawful entry and petit larceny for pilfering flags from Michelle Logan and Jenna Burnett on multiple occasions: September 16, September 30, and January 27. Meanwhile, DiGregorio was charged with a single count of petit larceny for his involvement on January 21.

As the investigation unfolded, the surrounding community rallied in support of Logan and Burnett, demonstrating solidarity by displaying Pride flags outside their own homes. This collective action sent a powerful message of unity and resilience against acts of intolerance.

Alternative Justice Pathway

According to ARLnow, the legal proceedings took an unconventional turn when charges against DiGregorio were dismissed in September. Subsequently, on December 23, a district court judge dismissed the charges against Henshaw. Both soldiers had successfully completed the Heart of Safety Restorative Justice Conferencing Program, a progressive initiative aimed at providing alternatives to incarceration.

In a statement to the Washington Blade, Arlington Commonwealth’s Attorney Parisa Dehghni-Tafti elaborated on the program’s intent, "The goal is to offer a path that fosters accountability without resorting to imprisonment. It necessitates a voluntary agreement from both the accused and the victims." The program emphasizes dialogue, requiring offenders to confront their actions, often face-to-face with the victims, and to pledge improvement.

Henshaw and DiGregorio, as part of the program, acknowledged their misdeeds, participated in counseling sessions over six months, and had meaningful interactions with Logan and Burnett.

A Learning Opportunity

Michelle Logan expressed her thoughts to ARLnow, "We believed they had the capacity for change. Simply marking their records with charges didn’t seem sufficient. We wanted them to learn and understand that stealing a Pride flag is not only a criminal act but also a hate crime that deeply impacts the victims."

After initial meetings with the soldiers, Logan and Burnett devised a constructive task aimed at enriching the soldiers' understanding of LGBTQ+ issues and allyship. This educational assignment was a unique aspect of the restorative justice approach, focusing on awareness and empathy.

The incidents were well-documented, as Logan and Burnett’s home security camera captured the thefts. The footage, shared widely on social media, played a pivotal role in identifying the culprits, thanks to tips from the online community.

In response to the thefts, Logan and Burnett adopted a proactive stance by donating $100 to an LGBTQ+ charity each time their flags were stolen. This initiative not only turned a negative experience into a positive impact but also inspired others to contribute. Over time, they managed to raise over $1,000 for the Trevor Project through a social media campaign.

The resolution of this case through restorative justice highlights a growing interest in alternative methods of conflict resolution, particularly in instances involving bias-motivated crimes. By focusing on education and reconciliation, it offers a blueprint for transforming a negative act into an opportunity for growth and understanding.

Stay informed and connected with issues affecting your community by subscribing to our newsletter. Be the first to learn about events and stories that shape LGBTQ+ communities worldwide.